Reality Check India

No issues of any kind this election

Posted in Uncategorized by realitycheck on May 17, 2009

Firstly, this was an issueless election. Please,  nobody won on any issue.  You cannot invent issues after the fact.

There is understandable elation at the Congress camp.  I respect those who cheer the fact that Advani led BJP lost, at least they are honest about it.  Then there are the social justice (the no data version) champions.  They too are happy, the same way  crooks are happy after a heist. Well, everyone arrives at the party with their own bottle of booze.  No hard feelings.

Personally, I am not too disappointed.  I think the current winning combination is better than the last. The BJP has not expanded its base, which must worry them. They have nowhere to recoup losses in their base states.  The Congress simply swallowed up the Left and Fourth Front.  I have said that the left will die out in West Bengal simply because the Muslims will desert it, thanks to the Sachar report.  The communists do have a narrow window to attach the poor bengali muslims to quota benefits, but they do not seem to get it.   Mulayam simply forgot to take care of the narrow interest in his custody and paid the price.

The Congress is sure to choke the country and further pursue its divisive agenda.  Gasp ! If I were on TV now, the anchors would have turned red. Divisive agenda based on caste is apparently not only kosher but necessary. 

I am exasperated at the BJP for three reasons,

1. It lets others define it. This is a recipe for political disaster. I remember the political commentator John Carville years ago in the US repeatedly stress this point. In interview after interview, the BJP guests let the words like “communal force” go by unchallenged even while being aware of the connotations. 

2. It does not define itself. If the BJP is for Hindu rights, where was it in Malaysia or Sri Lanka ? It did not make a big deal about the Spectrum scam (which I think is a hidden factor in this election). Either it did some adjustments on the scam or was unable to make an issue out of it.  Both scenarios are disturbing.   Still its work on the Ram Sethu is appreciated.

3. The quota issue completely caught the BJP by surprise. It went along with the Congress. No one can beat the Congress unless it changes the terrain in which social justice wars happen in this country. It was unable to explain the Kandhamal happenings in terms of the quota system, which was its root cause.  It did not realize that the middle class is orthogonal to backwardness. The quota system permanently gifted a large chunk of middle class voters to the Congress. Try holding a poll among Delhi University students and families if you want to see the impact of the quota system.

I still support the BJP because it still presents the best challenge to the Congress. I can never reconcile with the Congress party’s policies which are nothing but naked corruption and greed with presentable facades such as social justice and concern for the poor.  We have had this for decades now. While the world has marched forward we still live largely in filth and misery. This version of socialism and truth do not go together.

5 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. borneveryday said, on May 18, 2009 at 11:22 am

    This result is a lot better than what would have happened in a fractured verdict. It would have been a nightmare to watch the smaller fringe parties throw their weight around in the government, asking for a larger piece of the pie.

  2. Barbarindian said, on May 19, 2009 at 4:21 am

    On streaming video CNN-IBN appears to be showing Rajapaksa speech complete with Sri Lankan national anthems, cute little choir girls etc. The tone of the coverage is almost the same as Indian independence day celebrations.

    Am I getting this right?

    Meanwhile the breaking news ticker on the Times of India says “Tamil website claims Prabhakaran alive”.

  3. rc said, on May 19, 2009 at 6:22 am

    I watched a bit of the military celebrations yesterday.

    I am afraid the Sinhalese political parties are not as mature as people in India think. Most consider this is a victory over Tamils.

    Highly unlikely the Tamils will get even the space they had in the 70’s.

    Gen Fonseka just returned from Beijing yesterday. From the visuals one can see the dramatic improvement in the SL forces armour, uniforms, and weaponry.

    But, no one cares in India about the grand foreign policy failure as demonstrated in the elections. Just uttering the word “LTTE” stimulates instant clouding of the brain.


    The good thing is several of my wild theories have been validated on the ground. The loss of PMK is the best example of failure of a group to protect its narrow interests by working very hard for a larger interest.

  4. Revathi said, on May 19, 2009 at 2:21 pm

    I agree with you RC, it is a disaster for the tamils. the wedge between the two communities is deeper than ever. I foresee large scale migration of the tamils into India and the dream come true for the sinhalese.

  5. […] 5 2009 : No issues of any kind this election It does not define itself. If the BJP is for Hindu rights, where was it in Malaysia or Sri Lanka ? […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: