Reality Check India

Tatkal or the art of mastering pervasive socialist shortage

Posted in Uncategorized by realitycheck on July 10, 2012

A new Tatkal scheme was announced today amidst much fanfare by the Minister of State for Railways Shri Muniyappa. It features clever and innovative checks to thwart misuse.  Keep in mind that “misuse” in this context means, purchasing a train ticket to go from City A to City B paying above normal rates.

  • Can book from 10AM instead of 8AM
  • Separate counters for Tatkal, or some counters will exclusively accept Tatkal from 10 to 10:30
  • Agents only allowed after 12PM
  • Bandwidth increased from 325 to 424 MBPS
  • Only 2 tickets per IP address, this is to thwart many people from same company booking or internet cafes.
  • CCTV Cameras will be installed at all booking counters to check agents
  • No cellphones allowed near booking counters.
  • If someone is booking on your behalf, your self attested ID as well as a Xerox and original or the person booking has to be produced.
  • Cash card stopped between 10AM-12PM
  • Single session per login has been implemented. If you use your ID once and book a ticket you are done for the day. Read this in conjunction with IP Address check, you cant go to another desk and book again.
  • IT Anti Fraud squad has been created at major centres, constant network surveillance is put in place to detect misuse.

Source : Desh Gujarat

This just blows my mind.  Lost in this hairball is the fact that these people are not trying to do anything illegal. They just want to go home. Essentially this is a massive failure of the state run Railways to live up to the demand of the people. The whole Tatkal scheme is an machine designed to place a logistical and monetary hurdle and discourage people from even trying to travel by train. Even if many say “f** it I am taking the bus”, the overflow numbers are so huge that Indians are forced to innovate to get a ticket. Touts are mere vehicles that provide the much needed service for a markup.

The socialist state does not  even recognize an equilibrium state of demand and supply. The supply is  the plan and bizzarro schemes like Tatkal complete with CCTV cameras are used to squeeze out the demand.  Fit the plan, not plan the fit.

It has gotten so bad that people sometimes look at me crazy when I say I came by Train on 2 weeks notice. How did you manage a ticket ?



5 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. plainspeak said, on July 10, 2012 at 6:47 pm

    “If someone is booking on your behalf, your self attested ID as well as a Xerox and original or the person booking has to be produced.”

    Or the person booking has to be produced. Ha ha.

    My solution is to auction the tickets for a few years. Anyway there is more demand than supply. So, why not give tickets to those who an afford to pay more than those who use touts?. Will get some good revenue. Put it back in the Railways.

  2. Raju said, on July 11, 2012 at 9:38 am

    All these measures are to prevent Agents booking Tatkal tickets in bulk and then selling it in black at higher prices. It was happening very rampantly, and everyone knew it. It took a expose on TV for railways to take action.
    I don’t say the steps are very good, but it would have been very good if the real reason for this steps were mentioned at least once.

    Please note that don’t use your experience of that pathetic IRCTC to make opinion about railways ticket booking. IRCTC accounts for a minuscule number of tickets sold, bulk of the tickets are sold through Railways e-ticketing system. which are used by agents, and the IP address and login IDs mentioned in the steps are specially referring to those Agent’s terminals.

  3. Mahesh said, on July 21, 2012 at 4:20 pm

    I feel this has to be one of the very few rare posts,RC, where I could not concur with you.

    • rc said, on July 22, 2012 at 3:13 am

      Thats okay 🙂

      There is no workaround for shortage. These clever steps will amount to nothing once initial disruption clears

  4. vikas g. said, on August 22, 2012 at 2:51 am

    Reblogged this on नेता जी कहिन.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: